An open question for people working inside local authorities — and for researchers who have successfully found their way in
There is a particular kind of rejection that is surprisingly pleasant when you are building a European research consortium and seeking municipal research collaboration. It usually says something like: “Thank you for contacting us. Unfortunately, this isn’t something we can participate in at the moment.”
Lovely.
Not the answer we wanted, obviously, but it is an answer. We know where we stand. We thank them for replying, close that particular door and try another one. Even better is the person who says, “This isn’t my area, but I think you need my colleague in Mobility. I’ve copied her in.” At that point, we may briefly consider naming a work package after them.
The difficult response is the one we encounter rather more often: nothing.
No yes. No no. No wrong department. No thank you, but we’re not interested. Not even you need Susan, and Susan sits three floors above me. Just silence.
After sending enough carefully researched emails into municipal cyberspace, we started wondering whether we had been asking the wrong question. Perhaps the question isn’t “Why aren’t municipalities answering us?” Perhaps it is:
What has to happen inside a municipality before an external research opportunity can receive an answer at all?
And that, we realised, is something we genuinely don’t understand.
Where does the email go?
At Add Lemonade, we have been developing European research proposals that need something rather important: real communities. Some of the problems we’re interested in don’t live neatly inside laboratories, universities or companies. They exist in neighbourhoods, public spaces, services and people’s everyday lives.
That means local authorities can bring something to research that the rest of a consortium cannot simply manufacture: knowledge of the place itself, its residents, its services, its constraints and its priorities.
So we started looking for municipalities. We identify a place that seems relevant. We try to understand something about the local context. We search the municipal website for the department most closely connected to the problem. Where possible, we identify an actual person. Then we write an email explaining what we’re investigating, why we approached that particular place and what involvement might mean.
Then we press Send.
Sometimes we receive an answer. Sometimes we don’t.
The curious thing is that we don’t particularly mind hearing no. A rejection gives us information. Perhaps the timing is wrong. Perhaps the project isn’t relevant locally. Perhaps there isn’t enough capacity to participate. Whatever the reason, a no allows everybody to move on.
Silence is different because silence contains almost no information.
Did anyone read the email? Did it reach the wrong department? Was it forwarded somewhere else? Did somebody think the idea was interesting but not know who had authority to take it further? Would answering create another task in an already overloaded diary? Did the project cross so many departmental boundaries that nobody was quite sure who owned it?
Did an unfamiliar SME talking about European research simply look like somebody trying to sell something?
Or perhaps our email wasn’t very good. That possibility has to remain on the table too.
All of these explanations produce exactly the same result from our side of the screen: no reply.
The mysterious middle
Once we started thinking about it this way, the unanswered email became rather more interesting.
An external research opportunity presumably has to make a journey through an organisation. Somebody has to notice it, recognise that it might be relevant, route it to an appropriate person, decide whether somebody should take ownership of it, establish what participation would involve, consider capacity and authority and eventually make some kind of decision.
Opportunity arrives → relevance recognised → routed → owner found → assessed → authority involved → decision
We can see where that journey begins because we press Send. Occasionally, we see where it ends because somebody replies. It’s everything in the middle that we cannot see.
And an opportunity could presumably disappear at any one of those transitions.
If external organisations cannot identify the appropriate person, perhaps the bottleneck is access. If the message arrives but cannot easily be allocated, perhaps it is routing. If somebody likes the idea but doesn’t have the authority to progress it, perhaps it is ownership or decision-making. If staff are already operating at capacity, perhaps there simply isn’t enough time to investigate another possibility. And if established partners can telephone somebody they worked with on a previous project while newcomers begin with Dear Sir/Madam, perhaps relationships and trust matter too.
These are hypotheses, not findings about the municipalities we’ve contacted. But there are reasons to take them seriously.
OECD work on innovation capacity in cities identifies limited resources, administrative complexity, risk aversion and specialised organisational silos among barriers to municipal innovation. It also discusses fragmented structures and the difficulty of addressing complex challenges across policy areas.
The same OECD work treats a municipality’s openness to partnership — its ability to work with businesses, researchers, civil society and other external actors — as an important part of innovation capacity, alongside networks across departmental silos and partnerships outside government.
None of this proves why a particular email from Add Lemonade wasn’t answered. But it does suggest that what looks from outside like a simple communication problem may sometimes sit inside a much larger organisational one.
When a project belongs to everybody — and nobody
We have encountered another complication: the problems we’re interested in don’t necessarily respect municipal organisational charts.
Imagine a research project concerned with inclusive mobility, accessibility, social participation and neighbourhood environments. Who owns that? Mobility? Public health? Adult social care? Disability and accessibility? Sustainability? Community participation? Active travel? Potentially all of them.
A project can be relevant to several departments while belonging clearly to none of them.
An email reporting a broken streetlight presumably has somewhere relatively obvious to go. An email proposing a European research collaboration connecting mobility, disability, health, social participation and neighbourhood design may have a more adventurous journey.
Mobility suggests Community. Community thinks perhaps Public Health. Public Health suggests Sustainability. Sustainability’s automatic reply informs us that Gerald has retired.
We wish Gerald a long and happy retirement.
We still need a municipality.
There is a serious point underneath the joke. OECD work has highlighted “silo-busting” and inter-agency collaboration as part of strengthening innovation capacity, including approaches organised around cross-cutting problems rather than individual sectors.
Perhaps some external innovation opportunities encounter exactly the same boundaries internally that researchers are trying to cross externally.
We don’t know. And that’s why we’d rather ask than assume.
Perhaps we’re the strange ones
There is another perspective we have to consider: the recipient’s.
We know our project intimately. We’ve probably spent weeks discussing it. We know what the funding programme means, why the municipality matters and what we mean by a pilot, demonstration site or living lab.
The person receiving our email knows none of that.
Instead, somebody they’ve never met suddenly appears in their inbox talking about a European consortium, several countries, research organisations, neighbourhoods and a project that may not even be funded yet. And we’d quite like an answer soon because there is a deadline.
Perhaps we’re the strange ones.
What looks from our side like a simple question — “Would you be interested in a conversation?” — might immediately create ten questions on theirs. Who are these people? Why us? What exactly are they asking us to do? How much staff time will this require? Is there funding? Would residents be involved? Who internally would need to approve it? What happens if the proposal succeeds? And what exactly have I accidentally volunteered my municipality for if I reply to Bianca?
Fair questions.
Capacity matters here too. OECD work notes that overstretched staff, constrained budgets and growing demands on municipal services can leave limited space for experimentation and new approaches. A message can therefore be relevant and potentially interesting without becoming urgent enough to survive everything else competing for attention.
So perhaps silence isn’t rejection at all. But perhaps sometimes it is. From outside, we simply cannot tell.
So we’re asking the people who know
This is the point where an article like this would normally offer Five Tips for Successfully Engaging Municipalities.
We’re not going to do that. We don’t know enough yet.
Instead, we would genuinely like to hear from people who can see the part of this process that we cannot.
If you work, or have worked, inside a municipality or local authority, what actually happens when an unsolicited research or innovation collaboration arrives? Does it have an obvious route through the organisation? Who decides where it goes? What makes you respond? What makes you forward it? What information would make it easier to assess? And what makes something potentially interesting disappear without anybody ever saying no?
We would equally like to hear from researchers, universities, SMEs and innovators who have successfully established municipal partnerships. How did you first get through the door? Was it a cold email? An introduction? A university connection? A European network? A conference? An existing relationship? Or did you discover a route that newcomers rarely know exists?
And if our approach is wrong, please tell us that too. That might be the most useful answer of all.
At the moment, we have hypotheses. The bottleneck might be access, routing, ownership, capacity, authority, trust — or something we haven’t thought of yet. Before proposing a solution, we’d rather understand the problem.
So this article is deliberately unfinished in one sense. It is an open question from one side of the municipal inbox to the other.
We can see where the email leaves us. You can see what happens after it arrives. We’d love your help understanding the bit in between.
And if enough people answer, we’ll come back with Part Two: What Actually Happens to Your Email After You Send It to a Municipality?
Hopefully, Gerald forwarded it before he retired. 🍋
References
- OECD (2019). Enhancing Innovation Capacity in City Government. OECD Publishing, Paris.
- OECD (2021). Innovation and Data Use in Cities: A Road to Increased Well-being. OECD Publishing, Paris.
